AI isn’t just changing how people shop; it’s rewriting the rules. In 2026, the customer journey looks very different from the linear paths brands once designed. During the holiday season, AI and AI agents influenced 20% of all retail sales, fueling $262 billion in revenue (Yahoo, 2026). Shoppers aren’t just browsing; they’re turning to AI for inspiration, discovery and decisions that lead to real purchases.

Consumers now expect speed, certainty, and trust. They want brands to match their style of shopping the journey. The opportunity is clear: brands that lean into AI to co-create personalized, responsive experiences will win loyalty and growth.

Conversion rates for visitors arriving via AI assistants is 38% higher compared to traditional sources, revealing deep trust in AI to surface the best options (Inc. 2025).

Why the Old Model Falls Short

The first wave of personalization was built on prediction: automating journeys around what brands thought customers would do next. But the “next best action” model assumes a linear journey. In reality, customers loop, pause and explore on their own terms. Now, when personalization feels off, 66% of customers disengage or unsubscribe (BCG 2024). Mis-timed recommendations erode confidence fast.

Brands that meet customers by executing personalization at the right moments can see 10–15% revenue lifts and up to 30% ROI improvements (McKinsey 2025). Personalization needs a rethink.‍

• ‍53% of customers hit decision-making pitfalls, feeling rushed, conflicted, overwhelmed, or doubtful (Gartner 2025)

‍

The New Era: Participation and Empowerment

Today’s customers expect choice and control. Leading brands are moving beyond static funnels to active personalization, experiences that let customers steer, correct and deepen engagement. This can look like micro-participation moments—a single smart question or a preference toggle that turns small choices into big wins. These moments can reduce cognitive load, build trust, and drive results: 25% higher conversion, 15% revenue growth, and 30% higher retention (Forrester 2025).‍

• ‍79% of consumers feel more positive toward brands that tailor their ads based on their preferences (IAB 2025)

‍

How to Become an Active Brand

Active personalization is the bridge to conversational, AI-enabled experiences. Trust now comes from choice and agency, not rigid optimizations. It isn’t about predicting the next steps; it’s about inviting consumers to participate in creating the next step for them. Brands that empower customers with choice and agency will build trust, loyalty and growth in this agentic era.

• 30-50% of quiz funnels convert compared to 3–10% for traditional lead magnets (ScoreApp 2025)‍
• 87% of organizations that leverage AI-driven personalization combined with interactive choice mechanisms have seen measurable boosts in customer engagement (Adobe 2025)
• ‍40% less likely to complete a high-quality purchase when communication isn’t tailored to their role or intent (Gartner 2025)

Here are a few ways to start enabling moments of participation:

• Insert micro-participation moments: Create small, quick, contextual interactions, like a single question or toggle, that give customers control without slowing their journey.
• Design for aligned, skippable experiences: Match content to intent of the interaction, format and level of impact of the purchase or decision being made. Consider what information should be critical or customizable for low-risk daily purchases compared major financial decisions.
• Make data  sharing a value exchange: Ask for relevant data at the right time and show how it improves the experience, like when a ride sharing app asks for location data to find the fastest pickup near you.
• Interpret real-time signals: Use AI to read behaviors, like idle time or hesitation, and respond with timely, helpful interventions.

The Bottom Line

Personalization shouldn’t be passive anymore. Powered by AI, it can be a collaborative tool that brands should use to build trust, loyalty and power growth. The question isn’t if you’ll adapt, but how fast.